Chapter 06 · 1925–1927

The lastchapter

Twenty-six months between an arrest at Shahjahanpur and a morning at Gorakhpur. Most of it was spent in a courtroom.

26.09.1925

Arrested at Shahjahanpur

The arrestSeven weeks after Kakori

The killing of a passenger on a public train guaranteed that the investigation would be pursued with the full resources of the colonial police. It moved quickly. Ram Prasad Bismil was arrested on 26 September 1925; a small number of sources give the date as 26 October. Arrests continued across the United Provinces and into Bengal until some forty people were in custody.

Those detained included men who had been nowhere near the train. The prosecution was framed as a conspiracy case, and a conspiracy charge reaches membership and association rather than only presence at an event. That framing is the single most important fact about what followed: it is what turned an incident on a railway line into a proceeding against an entire organisation.

1926

The Kakori Conspiracy Case · Lucknow

The trialEighteen months in a Lucknow courtroom

Proceedings opened before the Special Sessions Judge A. Hamilton at Lucknow in May 1926 and continued for approximately eighteen months. The charges combined conspiracy against the Crown with the offences committed on the train, including the death of Ahmad Ali.

The accused were represented by a substantial body of counsel, several of whom were significant figures in Indian public life then or later: Govind Ballabh Pant, who would become the first Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh and Union Home Minister; Mohanlal Saksena; Chandra Bhanu Gupta; Kripa Shankar Hajela; and others. Their willingness to appear is itself evidence of how the case was regarded — not as ordinary crime, but as a political prosecution in which the nationalist bar had a stake.

Ashfaqulla Khan was not among the original accused. He was arrested in December 1926, after the main trial was already well advanced, and was tried in a supplementary proceeding.

Judgment delivered 6 April 1927 — principal sentences
AccusedSentence
Ram Prasad BismilDeath
Rajendra Nath LahiriDeath
Thakur Roshan SinghDeath
Ashfaqulla KhanDeath — on the supplementary trial following his later arrest
Sachindra Nath SanyalTransportation for life
Manmath Nath GuptaFourteen years
Jogesh Chandra Chatterjee, Govind Charan Kar, Raj Kumar Sinha, Ram Krishna Khatri, Mukundi LalTen years
Suresh Chandra Bhattacharya, Vishnu Sharan DublishSeven years
Bhupendra Nath Sanyal, Ram Dulare Trivedi, Prem Krishna Khanna, Pranawesh ChatterjeeFive years
Ram Nath Pandey, Banwari LalThree years

The appealsEvery route was taken, and every route closed

An appeal was carried to the Chief Court of Oudh on 18 July 1927. Judgment was delivered on 22 August 1927 and the death sentences were upheld.

What followed was a political campaign rather than a legal one, and it drew in nationalist leaders who rejected the revolutionaries' methods entirely. A mercy petition signed by seventy-eight members of the Central Legislature — among the supporters were Motilal Nehru, Madan Mohan Malaviya, Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Lala Lajpat Rai, Jawaharlal Nehru and Ganesh Shankar Vidyarthi — was submitted to the Viceroy. Lord Irwin rejected it on 9 September 1927.

A final appeal to the Privy Council in London was made in September 1927 and refused. An appeal to the King was also refused. The Government directed that the four sentences be carried out by 19 December 1927.

1927

Gorakhpur Jail

The final monthsWhat he did with the time

Bismil spent the last part of his life in the condemned cell at Gorakhpur, and he spent it writing. The autobiography he produced there was begun in prison and finished within days of the end. It left the jail in instalments and was published the following year by Ganesh Shankar Vidyarthi from the Pratap Press at Cawnpore under the cover title Kakori ke Shaheed.

The book is the primary source for most of what is known about his childhood and his own account of his political decisions. That a man under sentence of death chose to spend his remaining time composing a careful narrative of his life — rather than a statement, a protest or a farewell — says something about him that no later characterisation improves on.

On 18 December 1927 his mother, Moolmati, came to the jail to see him. Accounts of the meeting record that he wept and that she did not. She is reported to have told him that she was proud of him. The exchange has been retold many times and in many forms; the fact of the visit on that date is well established, and this website reports the visit rather than any particular version of the words.

19 December 1927The four

The sentences were carried out in four different jails. Rajendra Nath Lahiri was hanged two days before the others.

Rajendra Nath LahiriGonda Jail · aged 26

17 Dec 1927

Ram Prasad BismilGorakhpur Jail · aged 30

19 Dec 1927

Ashfaqulla KhanFaizabad Jail · aged 27

19 Dec 1927

Thakur Roshan SinghNaini Jail, Allahabad · aged 35

19 Dec 1927

Bismil's body was brought out of the jail and taken through Gorakhpur, where it was placed near the Ghantaghar — the clock tower — so that the public could see it. It was then carried to the bank of the Rapti and cremated according to Vedic rites. The place afterwards came to be called Rajghat, and it remains a site of commemoration in the city.

Historical memory

Evidence, and what was added afterwards

A century of retelling has attached a great deal to these four men. Separating the two columns is not disrespect — it is the only way the documented record survives at all.

Supported by the record

  • The dates, jails and sentences set out above, which appear in the case documents.
  • That Bismil wrote an autobiography in prison and that it was published in 1928 by Ganesh Shankar Vidyarthi.
  • That the Criminal Investigation Department produced its own translation of that book and circulated it confidentially for police use.
  • That Moolmati visited her son at Gorakhpur on 18 December 1927.
  • That leading Congress and Muslim League figures petitioned for commutation, and that the petition was rejected on 9 September 1927.
  • That the body was shown publicly in Gorakhpur and cremated on the bank of the Rapti.

Added by later retelling

  • Verbatim dialogue from the condemned cell, and from the meeting with his mother. Versions differ from source to source.
  • Detailed accounts of interior states — what he felt, hoped or feared — presented as though observed.
  • Poems and epigrams attributed to him on the strength of popularity rather than evidence.
  • A tidy narrative of friendship and brotherhood between the accused, elaborated well beyond what the trial record or the memoirs establish.
  • Numbers — of mourners, of crowds, of copies of proscribed books — that circulate without any traceable source.

Why the right-hand column exists. Nothing in it is necessarily false. Some of it may well be true. The point is that it cannot be checked, and a website that presented it as established fact would be teaching students to accept unverifiable claims about the past. The documented life is remarkable enough without additions.

What happened to his memory